What Three Years of Hiring Taught Me About Myself
The hires that did not work were rarely the hires I regret. What I regret is the version of me that made those calls.
For the last three years, I have been building a team.
Not a team on paper. Not a LinkedIn headcount. An actual group of people showing up every day for something I started from almost nothing. Along the way I have hired well, hired badly, held on too long, let go too late, trusted the wrong people, and sometimes missed the right ones sitting right in front of me.
Every founder I know has their own version of this list. Most of us do not talk about it in public, because it sounds like we are blaming the people who left. We are not. We are slowly learning that the only person a founder can actually hold accountable for the shape of the team is themselves.
This post is my version of that learning.
I confused closeness with loyalty
Early on, I treated certain people like family. If someone worked closely with me, if they handled sensitive things, if they were there for the hard conversations, I quietly started expecting them to stay like family too.
That was my error, not theirs.
Nobody signs a contract to be family. They sign up to do a job. The weight of unspoken expectation I was loading onto certain people was never fair to them, and it set me up to feel betrayed when they eventually did what any employee is entitled to do. Leave. Pursue their own thing. Take a better offer. Choose themselves.
The version of me that confused closeness with loyalty was always going to feel let down. The problem was never the people. The problem was the expectation I had never named, not even to myself, let alone to them.
Looking back, this is the single biggest shift in how I lead now. Warmth is not a contract. Closeness is not a bond. The people around me are choosing to be here, one day at a time, and that is actually the healthier arrangement for everyone.
I kept people in rooms they had not earned yet
The second mistake took me longer to see.
I started pulling certain people into conversations they had no real reason to be in. Management decisions. Strategy calls. Sensitive context about where the company was going, where the money sat, where the gaps were. I told myself I was building trust. I told myself I was being a transparent founder.
Looking back, I was outsourcing my own loneliness.
Founding is lonely for a reason. There are decisions only the founder can make, risks only the founder carries, and uncertainty only the founder has to sit with. Sharing that weight with the wrong person does not make it lighter. It just creates a new kind of exposure.
The rooms matter. Who sits in which room, who hears what, who gets access to what context, these are leadership decisions, not emotional ones. I was making them emotionally and calling it trust.
The team I have now understands this. Access to the hard rooms is earned by output, by judgment, by time. Not by proximity to me.
I ignored the signals
The third mistake is the one that still humbles me.
When someone’s engagement changed, when their energy shifted, when they started showing up in a different way, I did what a lot of founders do. I convinced myself I was imagining it. I told myself the person was tired, or stressed, or going through something personal, and that it would pass.
The signals were always right. I was just not ready to act on them.
By the time I did act, the situation was already costing the team more than it needed to. A founder’s job includes reading the room honestly, even when the room is not telling you what you want to hear. I was reading the room selectively. I only wanted to see the version that confirmed my hire.
Now I pay attention to the small things. The tone in a Slack message that shifts over a week. The way someone stops bringing new ideas. The meetings where they are present but not there. These are data. The data is almost always telling you the truth before the person is.
What changed
Three years of this has made me more careful. Not more guarded. Not colder. Just clearer.
Clearer about where the line between founder and friend sits. Clearer about who earns access to which room. Clearer about what my team actually owes me, which is honest work, and what they do not owe me, which is loyalty for life.
The quiet gift inside all of this is that the people on my team right now are here because they chose to be, not because I needed them to be. That is a different kind of trust. It is lighter. It does not break the way the other kind did, because it was never asked to carry what it could not carry.
There are still many lessons left. Every new quarter brings a new version of the same question. Am I reading this situation clearly, or am I reading it the way I want to read it? Am I expecting from this person what I have never named out loud? Am I in the room I should be in, or the one that feels comfortable?
Three years ago I would have answered those questions quickly. Today I sit with them longer. That is the whole shift.
If you are building a team right now
The only advice I would give a newer founder is this.
Do not confuse closeness with loyalty. Do not pull people into rooms they have not earned yet. Do not ignore signals because you do not want them to be true. And do not write the story of your team as if the people in it owe you something they never agreed to.
They are not family. They are not villains. They are people doing a job, choosing to spend some part of their life inside the thing you are building. Hold that lightly, and the team holds up better.
Hold it too tightly, and both of you lose.
One last thing
Every founder has a story about a hire that did not work out. I have more than one. I will probably have more before I am done.
What has changed is that I no longer carry those stories as grievances. I carry them as reminders of the version of me that made those calls, and the version of me I am trying to become because of them.
That is the whole post, really. The team did not fail me. The earlier me failed the team. And every quarter I get a little better at seeing the gap between those two things.
One question for you
What did your last three years of leading teach you about yourself, rather than about the people you led?
If the honest answer makes you uncomfortable, that is probably the right answer to sit with.
Notes from the desk
New writing, experiments, and the occasional story — straight to your inbox. Two to four emails a month.
Suraj Shrivastava
Founder of SERP Forge, the organic growth engine for B2B SaaS. I write here about building the company, experiments with AI and search, and the occasional life detour.